By Casandra Lanton, Esq. | Lanton, Lanton & Sosa Law PLLC
If your attorney uses artificial intelligence to draft a contract or conduct legal research, should your legal bill be lower?
In some cases, yes. Technology that reduces the time needed to complete legal work should benefit clients. Attorneys who bill hourly cannot charge for time they did not spend working on a matter. At the same time, attorneys remain responsible for reviewing the work, protecting confidential information, and providing accurate legal advice.
AI is changing how law firms handle routine assignments. Documents that once required hours to prepare may now be drafted much faster. Legal research, contract reviews, and document summaries can also be completed more efficiently. For business clients, the reasonable expectation is that these improvements should reduce unnecessary costs without compromising the quality of legal representation.
What Are Clients Actually Paying For?
A business owner hiring an attorney to prepare an executive employment agreement needs more than a document containing standard contractual provisions. The agreement must account for applicable employment laws, compensation arrangements, confidentiality obligations, termination rights, and the company's business interests.
AI can help prepare a draft, but the attorney must determine whether its provisions are appropriate and enforceable. An agreement that looks professionally written can still expose a company to substantial legal or financial risk.
The same applies to commercial leases, acquisitions, operating agreements, and other business transactions. Clients hire attorneys to evaluate legal obligations, identify potential problems, negotiate terms, and recommend how to proceed.
An attorney's experience and judgment remain part of the service, regardless of the technology used to prepare the underlying documents.
Should AI Reduce Legal Fees?
The American Bar Association addressed this issue in Formal Opinion 512, issued in July 2024. The opinion explains that attorneys billing by the hour must charge for the time actually spent on a client's matter. An attorney cannot bill two hours for work completed in thirty minutes simply because the assignment traditionally required two hours.
Flat-fee arrangements operate differently. A client may agree to a fixed fee for a particular service, provided the fee is reasonable under applicable professional rules.
Clients should understand how their attorneys bill for legal services and whether technology is helping reduce the time spent on routine work. Efficiency benefits the law firm, but it should also benefit the client.
Confidentiality and Accountability Still Matter
Businesses routinely share sensitive information with their attorneys, including financial records, employee information, acquisition plans, and confidential agreements. Before using AI tools with client information, attorneys must evaluate how those systems store, process, and protect that information.
Not every AI platform offers the same confidentiality protections. Attorneys must take appropriate precautions and determine whether client disclosure or consent is required under the circumstances.
Accuracy presents another concern. AI systems can generate incorrect legal citations, misstate applicable law, or overlook facts that affect a legal recommendation. Attorneys must verify the information they rely upon and review documents before providing them to clients.
If an AI-generated contract contains an error or a legal memorandum relies on an inaccurate citation, the attorney remains professionally responsible for the work.
These obligations are not reduced simply because technology assisted with the assignment.
What Business Clients Should Expect
Clients should expect their attorneys to use available technology responsibly, complete assignments efficiently, and charge reasonable fees. They should also expect clear explanations of legal recommendations and the risks associated with important business decisions.
There is nothing unreasonable about asking an attorney whether AI is being used, how confidential information is protected, or whether technological efficiencies are reflected in legal fees.
AI can reduce the amount of time needed to perform certain legal tasks. It does not eliminate the need for an attorney who understands the client's business, applies the law correctly, and accepts responsibility for the advice provided.
Clients are paying for competent legal representation, professional judgment, and accountability. They should also receive the financial benefits of efficiency when technology makes legal work faster.
This article is for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice.